She locates a gun, but the Cupid masked killer jumps out from the darkness and sends them both tumbling down a staircase. She runs through the house, discovering Dorothy's room trashed and Paige and Ruthie's corpses. Kate becomes convinced that Adam is actually Jeremy, disguised by reconstructive surgery, and goes back into the house, only to find Adam waiting for her. After dialing the number, she follows the sound of a ringtone outside the house and discovers Vaughn's severed head in the pond. After being told by Lily's boyfriend that she did not arrive in Los Angeles as planned, Kate realizes she is also probably dead and calls Detective Vaughn who was assigned to the case. Kate claims that Campbell could be a suspect because they do not know anything about him or where he is, while Dorothy counters by accusing Adam, Kate's recovering alcoholic on-off boyfriend, who is now a journalist. The party disintegrates when the power cuts out, and Dorothy and Kate argue over who the killer is. The killer impales her in the shoulder with an electric drill before throwing it into the water, electrocuting her. At the party, Paige is attacked and trapped in a hot tub by the killer. After coming to the party to confront Dorothy with the truth about Campbell, Ruthie is thrown through a shower window by the killer, who then impales her neck on the glass. The others assume he has simply left Dorothy, angering her, to which Dorothy believes that they are jealous and still look at her as the "fat girl" of the group. On the morning of the party, the killer murders Campbell with an ax in the basement. The killer catches Gary in the act and hits him with a hot iron, then proceeds to brutally beat him to death with the object.Īs Valentine's Day approaches, Dorothy is planning a party at her family's estate. Meanwhile, Kate's neighbor Gary breaks into her apartment to steal her underwear. Dorothy admits to Kate and Paige that she lied to avoid being humiliated and that Jeremy never attacked her ruining his life by causing him to be beaten and sent to reform school. Upon contacting the police, they agree that the culprit can be Jeremy Melton. When they have not heard from Lily, the others assume she is in Los Angeles on a work trip. Lily becomes lost at the exhibit and the killer appears, who proceeds to shoot her repeatedly with arrows until she falls several floors into a dumpster. Meanwhile, Dorothy's boyfriend, Campbell, loses his apartment and temporarily moves in with her at her father's large mansion.Īs the girls attend the exhibit of Lily's artist boyfriend Max, they meet Campbell's bitter ex-girlfriend Ruthie, who accuses him of being a con artist. Lily's card comes with a box of chocolates which she finds are filled with maggots. Paige, Lily and Dorothy subsequently receive obscene cards, each signed "JM". They admit to not having seen her in some time after she moved from San Francisco to Los Angeles. The killer's nose bleeds as she dies.Īt Shelley's funeral, Kate, Lily, Paige, and Dorothy are questioned. After being attacked by someone in a trench coat and Cupid mask, Shelley is cornered in a cooler where she attempts to hide in a body bag, but the killer finds her before slitting her throat. After receiving a vulgar Valentine's card in her locker, Shelley discovers someone has taken the place of the cadaver they had been dissecting. Thirteen years later, in 2001, Shelley, now a medical student at UCLA, is at the morgue one evening studying for her medical exam. It is later revealed Jeremy was expelled and eventually transferred to reform school and juvenile hall, due to Lily, Paige, Shelley and Joe testifying against him for unwanted sexual advances towards Dorothy, and then ended up in a state-run mental institution. Joe and his friends publicly strip and severely beat Jeremy, and his nose starts bleeding under the distress. When the school bully Joe Tulga and his friends discover them, Dorothy claims that Jeremy sexually assaulted her. Their rich friend Dorothy accepts Jeremy's invitation and they proceed to secretly make out underneath the bleachers. The first three girls, Shelley, Lily, and Paige, reject him spitefully and cruelly, while the fourth girl, Kate, politely responds "maybe later". Valentine's Day dance in 1988 San Francisco, Jeremy Melton, an outcast student, asks four popular girls to dance.